Haymaker Thunderbird Menu
139 items in 19 sections · $4.00 – $112.00 · Restaurant in Peoria, AZ
Haymaker Thunderbird’s menu lists 139 dishes and drinks, grouped into Starters, Salads, Comfort Food, Dessert, Dessert - Ice Cream Shakes, and Burgers and more. Prices range from $4.00 to $112.00, and a typical item costs about $10.00. Popular choices include Pulled Pork Sliders, Chicken Tender Basket, Mama's Bread Pudding, Banana Cream Pie, and Haymaker.
Starters 8
- Pulled Pork Sliders$9.80
Topped with bourbon bbq sauce and pickles
- Angus Beef Sliders$10.00
Caramelized onions, 1000 island
- Fried Pickles$8.50
Beer battered pickle spears with 1000 island
- Fried Zucchini$8.50
Beer battered fresh zucchini with ranch
- Mini Ribbies$10.00
Slow-cooked ribs, bourbon bbq sauce, cut & served with apple cider slaw
- Onion Rings$7.00
Thick cut and served with bourbon bbq ranch
- Loaded Cheese Fries$10.00
Hickory smoked bacon, cheddar, crema
- Bone-In Wings$10.50
A full pound of bone-in wings. Choose a dry rub or get them tossed in one of our sauces
Salads 6
- Haymaker
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onion, croutons, feta, choice of dressing
- Caesar
Romaine, parmesan, croutons, creamy caesar dressing
- Wedge$8.00
Iceberg wedge, blue cheese crumbles, chopped bacon, cherry tomatoes, haystack onions, balsamic blue cheese dressing
- Bbq Chicken
Mixed greens, roasted corn, black beans, avocado, tomatoes, haystack onions, bourbon bbq sauce, ranch dressing
- California Grilled Chicken
Mixed greens, candied walnuts, dried cranberries, red onion, feta, granny smith apple slices, apple cider vinaigrette
- Southwestern Chicken
Mixed greens, black beans, roasted corn, tomatoes, cilantro, avocado, chipotle ranch dressing
Comfort Food 3
- Chicken Tender Basket$10.50
Hand-battered chicken tenders, fries, honey mustard toss these tenders in any of our wing sauces or dry rubs!
- Mama's Meatloaf$15.00
House made, blend of beef and pork meatloaf, smashed potatoes, broccoli
- Bbq Chicken$11.50
Grilled bbq chicken breast, brushed with bourbon bbq sauce, served with baked mac and cheese and broccoli
Dessert 1
- Mama's Bread Pudding$7.00
Don't miss this dessert! This is our world famous bread pudding with whiskey cream anglaise and vanilla ice cream. Best you will ever have!
Dessert - Ice Cream Shakes 5
- Banana Cream Pie$5.50
- Cookies & Cream$5.50
- Vanilla$5.50
- Chocolate$5.50
- Strawberry$5.50
Burgers 5
- Wrangler$11.30
American cheese, lettuce, tomato
- Kinda Famous Texan$12.30
Hickory smoked bacon, bourbon bbq sauce, cheddar, crispy haystack onions
- Classic Patti Melt$11.80
American cheese, caramelized onions, grilled sourdough
- Cardiologist$15.30
Pastrami, hickory smoked bacon, spicy brown mustard, swiss, pretzel bun
- Arizona$12.30
Green chiles, pepper jack cheese, caramelized onions
Bourbon - Traditional 25
- Ancient Age$6.00
- Angel's Envy$14.00
- Baker's$14.00
- Benchmark$7.00
- Blanton's$15.00
- Booker's$20.00
- Breckenridge$12.00
- Early Times$6.00
- E.h. Taylor Single Barrel$15.00
- E.h. Taylor Small Batch$14.00
- Elmer T Lee$14.00
- Evan Williams$6.00
- Evan Williams 1783$7.00
- Four Roses Yellow Label$7.00
- George T Stagg$19.00
- High West Campfire$19.00
(Peated)
- High West Prairie$8.00
- Hudson 4 Grain$24.00
- Hudson Baby Bourbon$14.00
- Hudson Single Malt$24.00
- Jim Beam$7.00
- Jim Beam Devil's Cut$7.00
- Knob Creek 100$9.00
- Stagg Jr.$12.00
- Stranahan$14.00
Bourbon - High Rye 10
- Basil Hayden's$11.00
- Buffalo Trace$8.00
- Bulleit$8.00
- Eagle Rare 10 Yr.$9.00
- Four Roses Single Barrel$11.00
- Four Roses Small Batch$10.00
- Garrison Bros$21.00
- High West Son Of Bourye$19.00
- Ridgemont Reserve 1792$8.00
- Wild Turkey 81$7.00
Bourbon - Wheated 4
- Maker's Mark$8.00
- Makers 46$9.00
- Weller 107$14.00
- Weller 12$15.00
Japanese 2
- Hibiki Harmony$19.00
- Yamizaki 12 Yr$26.00
(Peated)
Rye 16
- 1910 Pendleton Rye$11.00
- Angel's Envy Rye$19.00
- Bulleit Rye$8.00
- Crown Rye$9.00
- Dickel Rye$6.00
- E.h. Taylor Rye$17.00
- George Dickel Rye$6.00
- High West Double Rye$11.00
- Hudson Manhatten Rye$14.00
- Knob Creek Rye$9.00
- Redemption Rye$9.00
- Rock 'N' Rye$7.00
- Sazerac Rye$12.00
- Templeton Rye 4 Yr$10.00
- Templeton Rye 6 Yr$12.00
- Whistle Pig$20.00
Tennessee 6
- Dickel #8$6.00
- Dickel #12$7.00
- Jack Daniel's Black$7.00
- Gentleman Jack$10.00
- Jack Daniel's Single Barrel$11.00
- Jack Daniel's Frank Sinatra$32.00
Flavored 16
- Bird Dog Blackberry$7.00
- Bird Dog Chocolate$7.00
- Bird Dog Grapefruit$7.00
- Bird Dog Maple$7.00
- Bird Dog Peach$7.00
- Crown Royal Apple$8.00
- Croan Royal Maple$8.00
- Crown Royal Vanilla$8.00
- Fireball$4.00
- Jack Daniel's Honey$7.00
- Midnight Moon Apple Pie$7.00
- Midnight Moon Blackberry$7.00
- Midnight Moon Blueberry$7.00
- Midnight Moon Raspberry$7.00
- Midnight Moon Strawberry$7.00
- Wild Turkey Honey$7.00
Irish - Blended 9
- Bushmills$7.00
- Jameson$7.00
- Jameson Black Barrel$9.00
- Jameson Caskmates$8.00
- Scotchdale$12.00
- Tullamore Dew$7.00
- Tullamore Dew 12 Yr$13.00
- Tullamore Dew Phoenix$20.00
- Two Gingers$8.00
Irish - Single Pot Still 1
- Red Breast 12 Yr$16.00
Irish - Single Malt 2
- Tullamore Dew 10 Yr$12.00
- Tullamore Dew 14 Yr$15.00
Canadian 7
- Black Velvet$5.00
- Canadian Club$6.00
- Crown Royal$8.00
- Crown Royal Black$10.00
- Crown Royal Reserve$14.00
- Pendleton$7.00
- Pendleton Reserve$32.00
Pappy Van Winkle 4
- Old Rip Van Winkle: 10 Yr$50.00
A buttery mouthfeel, balanced, rich flavors ranging from caramel to roasted nuts, and a long, spicy finish.
- Van Winkle Special Reserve: 12 Year$68.00
Taste a round, supple entry, leading to a dry, expansive, medium body. Enjoy notes of caramel, nuts, and brown spices with a lengthy, enveloping finish.
- Pappy Van Winkle: 15 Year$80.00
Taste a rich, supple entry, leading to a decadent, huge, full- bodied palate with intense caramel, toffee and peppery brown spice flavors. Then, enjoy a finish with an extreme. Long, complex, evolving fade of spice and wood notes.
- Pappy Van Winkle: 20 Year$112.00
Full bodied bourbon is reminiscent of oiled leather, smoke, minerals, coffee and cigar boxes. Take in the endless ranges of aromatics and flavors.
Others 9
- T.a.b.$11.50
Oven roasted turkey, avocado, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat bread
- Grown Up Grilled Cheese$11.00
Cheddar, white american, brie, hickory smoked bacon, grilled tomato, grilled wheat bread
- French Dip$12.30
Slow cooked roast beef, sauteed mushrooms, carmelized onions, swiss, fresh roll with au jus
- Classic Tuna Melt$11.30
House made tuna salad, grilled with american, served on marble rye
- Famous Pulled Pork$10.00
Hand-pulled pork, topped with bourbon bbq sauce, and haystack onions, toasted brioche
- Hot & Heavy Pastrami$12.50
1/2 lb. Sliced pastrami, swiss, spicy brown mustard, grilled marble rye
- B.l.a.t.$10.00
Hickory smoked bacon, smashed avocado, deep-fried tomato, mayo, grilled texas toast
- Monterey Chicken Sandwich$13.30
Grilled chicken breast, hickory smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, smashed avocado, lettuce, tomato, sriracha aioli, brioche bun
- Buffalo Chicken$13.00
Hand battered fried chicken, tossed in house buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, grilled texas toast
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.